Unsurprisingly, I often get information about music gear popping up in my YouTube feed. One of the things that caught my eye in the past week was a collaboration between Loog Guitars and Fender to put out some 3 string basses and guitars with nods to classic Fender instruments (like this one). Fender are still in my bad books but I’m also not sure about whether a three stringed bass is a good choice for a child.
Loog suggest it is an easy way into playing guitar – better, in their estimation, than a ukulele. I’m a lot less sure. I do agree that someone learning an instrument needs more than an instrument shaped toy although, honestly, a lot of kids really just want an instrument shaped toy to bash around as they play. It is also true that playing a ukulele is not quite the same as playing a guitar. However, the skills are directly transferable and it is also true that a three stringed bass is not a regular bass. There’s nothing wrong with three stringed instruments but the range of notes and strings available is a fundamental characteristic of chordophonic instruments.
In particular, I think there are two significant obstacles placed in the way of those who want to learn rather than just to use a prop to support their imagination and play. Firstly, if you diligently learn scales, riffs and chords, you will have to relearn when switching up. I’ve been playing six string basses for more than half my playing lifetime and I’ve also spent a long time on alternative tunings but I’d say that I am most confident finding notes on the EADG bass fretboard I first learned on. I reckon that someone who makes a serious start on a three string bass is going to take a while not to favour those three strings when they get a regular bass. Secondly, a lot of available learning material assumes four strings so there will be plenty of stuff – including all sorts of classic songs – that will be difficult or impossible when you haven’t got that range under your fingers.
I won’t be adding a Loog guitar to my collection and I would be inclined to advise others against them for this reason. I’d be much happier if they presented themselves as a different type of instrument rather than pretending to be a learning tool to work towards actual guitars or basses.
